Tesla Model Y vs Volkswagen ID.4: Which EV is Right for You?

EV Models
1

I’m considering making the switch to an electric vehicle and have narrowed it down to the Tesla Model Y and the Volkswagen ID.4. I’m looking for real-world experiences and opinions on both of these midsize SUVs. Here are a few specific points I’d love to hear feedback on:

Performance & Range

  • How do the driving dynamics compare? Is one more fun to drive than the other?
  • What’s the real-world range like on both? Are there significant differences?

Interior Comfort

  • Which one feels more spacious and comfortable for long drives?
  • How’s the infotainment system in both? User-friendly or a hassle?

Cargo Space

  • How do they stack up in terms of cargo capacity?
  • Any notable features that give one an edge over the other?

Pricing & Value

  • Are there any hidden costs associated with either model?
  • Given the features, which one offers better overall value?

I’m looking forward to hearing your thoughts and experiences to help me make a more informed decision!

2

I’ve driven both the Model Y and the ID.4, and I have to say, the Tesla Model Y’s acceleration is mind-blowing! It feels like a rocket off the line compared to the ID.4.

3

I totally agree! The way it handles corners is also impressive. ID.4 feels a bit more stable, but lacks that sportiness.

4

I’ve only test-driven the Model Y, but I was shocked by its handling. It feels so responsive. I’m curious how the ID.4 compares at higher speeds.

5

I can tell you that it feels more composed, especially in turns. It’s geared more towards comfort than sportiness.

6 Likes
6

I love that the Model Y has a quick acceleration, but honestly, the ID.4’s interior is so spacious and has a more traditional feel. What’s everyone’s take on that?

3 Likes
7

Great point! The interior space is definitely a plus for the ID.4. But acceleration-wise, Model Y still wins in my experience.

8

Humorously, if you want to feel like you’re flying, the Model Y is your ride. The ID.4 is more like a comfortable train ride!

9

Haha, that’s a good analogy! I find it funny how different driving styles can be based purely on acceleration preferences.

10

If you prioritize sportiness, the Tesla has the edge. But sometimes I wonder if that balance between speed and everyday comfort is more crucial for most drivers.

11

That’s true! It’s really about personal preference. I think for families, the ID.4 might be better overall.

12

I found the Tesla’s handling to be superior, especially during aggressive driving. Has anyone experienced any handling issues with the ID.4?

13

Not really handling issues per se, but it does lean a bit more than the Model Y in tight turns.

14

I drive a Model Y and absolutely love its driving dynamics. But I think people focus too much on acceleration and miss the joy of a comfortable ride.

5 Likes
15

I feel you! My friend’s ID.4 is smoother and much quieter, making it a pleasant drive overall.

3 Likes
16

Thinking about the long-term reliability of both vehicles, I wonder if Tesla’s performance will remain consistent compared to the ID.4’s more sedate pace.

17

It’s a valid concern. Most reviews show that Tesla usually excels with performance, but ID.4’s approach might age better for typical drivers.

18

That’s an interesting point! I think the VW ID.4 might lack some advanced features, but I love its physical buttons for more straightforward operation.

19

I’ve researched both vehicles extensively. The Tesla Model Y has an impressive infotainment system with over-the-air updates that keep it fresh. Meanwhile, the ID.4’s interface feels more user-friendly for those not tech-savvy, which I find appealing.

20

I test drove both, and I have to say, the seating comfort in the Model Y is top-notch! The ID.4 was comfortable too, but the Model Y just felt more spacious.

5 Likes