Tesla Model Y vs Volkswagen ID.4: Which EV is Right for You?

I’m considering making the switch to an electric vehicle and have narrowed it down to the Tesla Model Y and the Volkswagen ID.4. I’m looking for real-world experiences and opinions on both of these midsize SUVs. Here are a few specific points I’d love to hear feedback on:

Performance & Range

  • How do the driving dynamics compare? Is one more fun to drive than the other?
  • What’s the real-world range like on both? Are there significant differences?

Interior Comfort

  • Which one feels more spacious and comfortable for long drives?
  • How’s the infotainment system in both? User-friendly or a hassle?

Cargo Space

  • How do they stack up in terms of cargo capacity?
  • Any notable features that give one an edge over the other?

Pricing & Value

  • Are there any hidden costs associated with either model?
  • Given the features, which one offers better overall value?

I’m looking forward to hearing your thoughts and experiences to help me make a more informed decision!

I’ve driven both the Model Y and the ID.4, and I have to say, the Tesla Model Y’s acceleration is mind-blowing! It feels like a rocket off the line compared to the ID.4.

I totally agree! The way it handles corners is also impressive. ID.4 feels a bit more stable, but lacks that sportiness.

I’ve only test-driven the Model Y, but I was shocked by its handling. It feels so responsive. I’m curious how the ID.4 compares at higher speeds.

I can tell you that it feels more composed, especially in turns. It’s geared more towards comfort than sportiness.

6 Likes

I love that the Model Y has a quick acceleration, but honestly, the ID.4’s interior is so spacious and has a more traditional feel. What’s everyone’s take on that?

3 Likes

Great point! The interior space is definitely a plus for the ID.4. But acceleration-wise, Model Y still wins in my experience.

Humorously, if you want to feel like you’re flying, the Model Y is your ride. The ID.4 is more like a comfortable train ride!

Haha, that’s a good analogy! I find it funny how different driving styles can be based purely on acceleration preferences.

If you prioritize sportiness, the Tesla has the edge. But sometimes I wonder if that balance between speed and everyday comfort is more crucial for most drivers.

That’s true! It’s really about personal preference. I think for families, the ID.4 might be better overall.

I found the Tesla’s handling to be superior, especially during aggressive driving. Has anyone experienced any handling issues with the ID.4?

Not really handling issues per se, but it does lean a bit more than the Model Y in tight turns.

I drive a Model Y and absolutely love its driving dynamics. But I think people focus too much on acceleration and miss the joy of a comfortable ride.

5 Likes

I feel you! My friend’s ID.4 is smoother and much quieter, making it a pleasant drive overall.

3 Likes

Thinking about the long-term reliability of both vehicles, I wonder if Tesla’s performance will remain consistent compared to the ID.4’s more sedate pace.

It’s a valid concern. Most reviews show that Tesla usually excels with performance, but ID.4’s approach might age better for typical drivers.

That’s an interesting point! I think the VW ID.4 might lack some advanced features, but I love its physical buttons for more straightforward operation.

I’ve researched both vehicles extensively. The Tesla Model Y has an impressive infotainment system with over-the-air updates that keep it fresh. Meanwhile, the ID.4’s interface feels more user-friendly for those not tech-savvy, which I find appealing.

I test drove both, and I have to say, the seating comfort in the Model Y is top-notch! The ID.4 was comfortable too, but the Model Y just felt more spacious.

5 Likes